Does the Individual Mandate Work?

This chart sits at the middle of a big controversy:

This is CBO’s estimate of how many people would skip buying health insurance if the individual mandate were repealed. Within two years, 12 million people would drop out, and they’d do it because the tax penalty for non-insurance went away: “In CBO and JCT’s estimation, with no penalty at all, only a small number of people who enroll in insurance because of the mandate under current law would continue to do so solely because of a willingness to comply with the law.”

Right now, the penalty is either $695 or 2.5 percent of your income. Very few people have a penalty greater than $1,500, while the cost of insurance is many times that. Is this really enough to motivate so many people to comply with the law? Republicans tend to think this is ridiculous, but both CBO and JCT have stuck to their guns on the mandate for years—and they aren’t staffed with idiots. Unfortunately, CBO is not in the business of explaining its methodology, so we have no way of knowing what this is based on.

But maybe we can take a crack at it ourselves by looking at other areas where individuals are fined for not obeying the law. Traffic offenses seem like a promising avenue of investigation, but there aren’t too many studies of how traffic fines correlate with breaking the law. However, a few years ago a study got released based on an increase in speeding fines in the Netherlands. It was especially noteworthy because the increase in fines could be checked against actual speeding, thanks to automated speed-measuring systems. The study’s conclusion is that fines have only a small effect: “If the fine increases by 1%, then the offence rate detected by an ASMS will decline by 0.14%.”

In the case of Obamacare, the penalty increased from zero, so we don’t have a percentage increase to work with. But let’s assume that for the average person this feels like a tripling of the fine. In that case, we’d expect a 28 percent decline in the offense rate. The total number of people uninsured before Obamacare took effect was about 45 million, which we can take as the starting “offense” rate. So that suggests the mandate was responsible for about 12-13 million people getting insurance.

There’s obviously a lot of guesswork here, since we don’t have a true baseline to work with. Nor do we know if the response to the mandate is similar to the response to speeding fines. Nonetheless, it gives us a ballpark kind of estimate, which matches up surprisingly well with CBO’s estimate. Apparently the individual mandate really does work.

NOTE: For what it’s worth, I did the arithmetic on this as I was writing the post. I didn’t know beforehand how it would turn out. Needless to say, I’d be interested in seeing similar correlations from other relevant studies.

UPDATE: This post originally contained a footnote about Adjusted Gross Income on your tax return, but it was wrong and didn’t really impact anything else very much. So I’ve deleted it.

AN IMPORTANT UPDATE

We’re falling behind our online fundraising goals and we can’t sustain coming up short on donations month after month. Perhaps you’ve heard? It is impossibly hard in the news business right now, with layoffs intensifying and fancy new startups and funding going kaput.

The crisis facing journalism and democracy isn’t going away anytime soon. And neither is Mother Jones, our readers, or our unique way of doing in-depth reporting that exists to bring about change.

Which is exactly why, despite the challenges we face, we just took a big gulp and joined forces with The Center for Investigative Reporting, a team of ace journalists who create the amazing podcast and public radio show Reveal.

If you can part with even just a few bucks, please help us pick up the pace of donations. We simply can’t afford to keep falling behind on our fundraising targets month after month.

Editor-in-Chief Clara Jeffery said it well to our team recently, and that team 100 percent includes readers like you who make it all possible: “This is a year to prove that we can pull off this merger, grow our audiences and impact, attract more funding and keep growing. More broadly, it’s a year when the very future of both journalism and democracy is on the line. We have to go for every important story, every reader/listener/viewer, and leave it all on the field. I’m very proud of all the hard work that’s gotten us to this moment, and confident that we can meet it.”

Let’s do this. If you can right now, please support Mother Jones and investigative journalism with an urgently needed donation today.

payment methods

AN IMPORTANT UPDATE

We’re falling behind our online fundraising goals and we can’t sustain coming up short on donations month after month. Perhaps you’ve heard? It is impossibly hard in the news business right now, with layoffs intensifying and fancy new startups and funding going kaput.

The crisis facing journalism and democracy isn’t going away anytime soon. And neither is Mother Jones, our readers, or our unique way of doing in-depth reporting that exists to bring about change.

Which is exactly why, despite the challenges we face, we just took a big gulp and joined forces with The Center for Investigative Reporting, a team of ace journalists who create the amazing podcast and public radio show Reveal.

If you can part with even just a few bucks, please help us pick up the pace of donations. We simply can’t afford to keep falling behind on our fundraising targets month after month.

Editor-in-Chief Clara Jeffery said it well to our team recently, and that team 100 percent includes readers like you who make it all possible: “This is a year to prove that we can pull off this merger, grow our audiences and impact, attract more funding and keep growing. More broadly, it’s a year when the very future of both journalism and democracy is on the line. We have to go for every important story, every reader/listener/viewer, and leave it all on the field. I’m very proud of all the hard work that’s gotten us to this moment, and confident that we can meet it.”

Let’s do this. If you can right now, please support Mother Jones and investigative journalism with an urgently needed donation today.

payment methods

We Recommend

Latest

Sign up for our free newsletter

Subscribe to the Mother Jones Daily to have our top stories delivered directly to your inbox.

Get our award-winning magazine

Save big on a full year of investigations, ideas, and insights.

Subscribe

Support our journalism

Help Mother Jones' reporters dig deep with a tax-deductible donation.

Donate