Climategate: Anatomy of a Scandal

Membership Ticker

Are there any guardrails left?

Autocratic forces are ascendant in America, but the story isn’t fully written. Truth-telling independent media is one remaining bulwark against the unrestrained exercise of power. At a time when billionaire owners of corporate media are making accommodations to power, our nonprofit newsroom cannot be bought, bent, or broken. Depend on it, and please stand with us.

Screenshot: Fox News

Fight disinformation: Sign up for the free Mother Jones Daily newsletter and follow the news that matters.

From the “hockey stick” graph to the hottest decade on record, a timeline of how Climategate really went down.

1988	NASA scientist James Hansen tells Congress the agency is “99% certain” record-high global temperatures are due to human activity.
1990	The UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) releases its first report (PDF), predicts that without a significant decrease in greenhouse gas emissions, the world will warm 0.5 degrees Fahrenheit per decade in the 21st century.
1997	World leaders adopt the Kyoto Protocol, which the US later refuses to ratify.
1999	Michael Mann introduces the now-infamous “hockey stick” graph. Global warming worries 3 in 10 Americans a “great deal.” 1990s confirmed as hottest decade in history.
JULY 28, 2003	Sen. James Inhofe (R-Okla.) calls global warming “the greatest hoax ever perpetrated on the American people.”
NOVEMBER 2003	Mining consultant Stephen McIntyre and economist Ross McKitrick publish a critique of Mann’s hockey stick (PDF), the first in a series of climate audits.
2004	Mann and a NASA climate modeler launch RealClimate, a blog “by working climate scientists.”
2005	McIntyre debuts Climate Audit, a skeptics’ blog, and publishes a second critique of Mann. The Wall Street Journal runs a front-page story, prompting House Republicans to launch an inquiry into Mann’s research (PDF).
2006	An Inconvenient Truth features Al Gore and the hockey-stick graph. It becomes the fifth-highest-grossing documentary in the US to date. 70% of Americans believe the Earth is warming, but are divided on whether humans are the cause.
2007	Gore and the IPCC win the Nobel Peace Prize.
2007-’09	McIntyre demands data from climate researchers, including those at the University of East Anglia (UEA). One laments that the endless requests are like a “McCarthy-style investigation.”
JUNE 2009	An unknown hacker attempts to break into the email accounts of five State Department employees who were working on climate change.
NOVEMBER 12-17, 2009	A hacker breaks into the CRU’s server and steals more than 4,500 emails and documents from Mann and other climate scientists.
NOVEMBER 17, 2009	The hacker tries to post a link to the emails on RealClimate. Similar links appear on several prominent skeptics’ blogs.
NOVEMBER 19, 2009	The story jumps from niche blogs to larger conservative echo chamber. Christopher Horner, a fellow at the oil-funded Competitive Enterprise Institute (CEI), calls the scandal a “blue-dress moment” in the National Review.
NOVEMBER 20, 2009	Phil Jones, who heads the CRU, confirms the email theft. The New York Times, the Wall Street Journal, and NPR run stories quoting portions of the emails. The Telegraph‘s James Delingpole picks up the term “Climategate” from the skeptic blog Watts Up With That? A few weeks later, Rep. James Sensenbrenner (R-Wis.) says the emails are evidence of “scientific fascism.“
NOVEMBER 21, 2009	CEI director Myron Ebell accuses scientists of “unethical conniving” in the Washington Post.
DECEMBER 19, 2009	The UN climate change conference in Copenhagen ends without any major international agreement on how to regulate greenhouse gas emissions.
2010	Numerous independent reviews (PDF) conclude the emails were cherry-picked and misconstrued. But half of Americans now believe global warming is “generally exaggerated.” Senate abandons a bill that would set the first-ever mandatory caps on US greenhouse gas emissions. The 2000s replace the 1990s as the hottest decade on record.
2011	McIntyre claims UEA is “stonewalling” requests for information on its investigation of the hack.