Immigrants are bad for the West: discuss

Facts matter: Sign up for the free Mother Jones Daily newsletter. Support our nonprofit reporting. Subscribe to our print magazine.


Writing at Tech Central Station, Jerry Bowyer, an avowed conservative Republican, poses a question he says he recently put to Pat Buchanan:

If 200 years from now America will be filled with people who know and love the ideas of Jefferson and Madison — but these people are overwhelmingly dark skinned — will this be good or bad?

Buchanan’s measured response: “a disaster and a tragedy”–identifying him obviously enough as as a “blood-and-soil conservative,” as against the “we-hold-these-truths-to-be-self-evident” kind, of which Bowyer is one. The problem for Buchanan and his ilk, says Bowyer, is that they’re on the wrong side of history.

America is a highly dynamic country. In fact, dynamism is the point of it, especially racial dynamism. When the first Congress commissioned that Adams, Franklin and Jefferson create a ‘great seal’ which would represent the ideals of our country, the (eventual) results included the Latin words “E Pluribus Unum”, From many, One. From many what? From many races. How could Jefferson and Franklin (who worked together on the Declaration of Independence) see it any other way? When they ‘declared’ to the world that rights were self-evident, they staked everything on the notion that the software of liberty runs on all varieties of human hardware.

History proved them right. …

But, wait, if we don’t send ’em all back to where they came from and erect electric fences from sea to shining sea won’t we, you know, utterly destroy the West and everything Anglo-Americans hold dear?. Well, no.

Immigration doesn’t represent the ‘death of the West’ it represents its renewal. People go from places that they don’t like to places that they do like. This implies that they ‘buy in’ to what we’re about to some degree. I would argue that immigrants tend to buy in to America more fervently than those of us who are born here. …

Immigrants start businesses at significantly higher rates than the native born. Entrepreneurship is risky. It’s difficult to imagine Silicon Valley occurring without immigrants from India. Immigrants have more children, which, of course, parents will recognize as the ultimate risk.

Do they change the culture? Of course, they do. Living cultures change, dead cultures don’t.

All of which strikes me as sensible, obvious, true, reasonable, humane…etc. That it makes Bowyer something of an outlier among his Republican pals–and not just the paleoconservative Buchanan types–is as alarming as it is ludicrous.

THE END...

of our fiscal year is Thursday, June 30, and we have a much larger fundraising gap than we can easily manage with only days left to go.

Right now is no time to come up short: If you value the hard-hitting, democracy-protecting, justice-advancing journalism you get from Mother Jones, please help us keep charging as hard as we possibly can with a much-needed and much-appreciated donation today.

payment methods

THE END...

of our fiscal year is Thursday, June 30, and we have a much larger fundraising gap than we can easily manage with only days left to go.

Right now is no time to come up short: If you value the hard-hitting, democracy-protecting, justice-advancing journalism you get from Mother Jones, please help us keep charging as hard as we possibly can with a much-needed and much-appreciated donation today.

payment methods

We Recommend

Latest

Sign up for our free newsletter

Subscribe to the Mother Jones Daily to have our top stories delivered directly to your inbox.

Get our award-winning magazine

Save big on a full year of investigations, ideas, and insights.

Subscribe

Support our journalism

Help Mother Jones' reporters dig deep with a tax-deductible donation.

Donate